The Isle of Man Government has revealed that they collected £21.3 million EXTRA in income tax than they budgeted for last year. This wasn’t planned. They don’t need it for any specific purpose. This extra tax should be returned to the people it was taken from: £473 for every income taxpayer on the Island.

Return the extra Manx tax

Dear SpeakOut! user

To the Treasury Minister of the Isle of Man,

We respectfully petition the Treasury to return the unexpected income tax windfall of £21.3 million to the income taxpayers of the Isle of Man.

The Facts The recently published Central Government Summary Management Accounts for the financial year 2024-25 reveal that Income Tax revenue exceeded budget expectations by £21.3 million. This windfall resulted from higher interest rates, causing higher income for some people.

The Principle This £21.3 million represents an unplanned and unexpected windfall. The government budgeted and planned its expenditure without this money. These funds were not collected for any specific purpose or policy. They are, quite simply, an unexpected overpayment by the hardworking taxpayers of our Island.

We believe that when the government collects more than it needs to deliver its planned services, those excess funds belong to the people who paid them. The government has no moral claim to retain money it neither intended to collect, nor requires, for its stated objectives.

The Proposal We propose a straightforward solution: return this windfall directly to those who paid it. With approximately 45,000 income taxpayers in the Isle of Man, this would mean each taxpayer receiving approximately £473. This is a meaningful sum that would provide real, practical benefit to Island residents.

This could be efficiently administered by issuing direct payments to everyone who paid income tax for the 2024-25 tax year.

The Benefits Such action would:

Provide immediate financial relief to working families;
Provide additional benefits to small businesses as residents spend these funds;
Demonstrate fiscal responsibility and respect for taxpayers;
Reinforce the principle that government should not take more is needed; and
Build trust between the government and the people of the Isle of Man.

Our Request We therefore respectfully petition the Treasury to:

Acknowledge that this windfall belongs to the taxpayers of the Isle of Man;
Commit to returning the full £21.3 million to income taxpayers; and
Implement a distribution mechanism to achieve this before the end of the current calendar year.

This is not merely a financial matter - it is a question of principle. When the government receives unexpected windfalls, the proper course is to return them to the people.

We urge you to take this opportunity to demonstrate that the Manx government stands with the people and return this extra windfall to the rightful owners: the people of the Isle of Man.

Respectfully submitted,

%%your signature%%

Share this with your friends:

The Government says that the extra tax was collected “due to factors such as higher interest rates“. This extra tax should be given back to the people who paid it.

That’s YOUR money.

The Government admits that this tax windfall came from higher interest rates. The accounts also reveals that the government already had enough money to deliver its planned services. This extra £21.3 million? It’s a windfall surplus. It is an overpayment by the public to the Government that belongs in your pocket, not government coffers.

Further, this extra tax was taken in error by the Treasury Department because they made a bad forecast. The Treasury Department shouldn’t take extra income tax because it made a bad forecast. That’s a recipe for further errors.

We’re Taking Action

The Manx TaxPayers’ Alliance has launched a petition to the Treasury Minister calling for this money to be returned to where it belongs: To you, the income taxpayers who paid it.

The proposal is simple: every one of the Island’s 45,000 income taxpayers should receive a payment of around £473. No complicated schemes. Minimum bureaucracy. Just your money, returned to you.

Why This Matters

Think what £473 could mean for your family:

  • Help with rising energy bills;
  • Extra support for grocery costs;
  • A boost to your savings; or
  • Simply money to spend in our local economy.

The government has already funded everything it planned to do. There’s no need to cut any services. This is about a fundamental principle: when government takes more than it needs, it should give it back.

We Need YOUR Voice

This campaign will only succeed if taxpayers across the Island stand together. The government needs to hear that we expect them to do the right thing.

Sign the petition today and demand your £473 back.

Share this with friends, family, and colleagues. Every income taxpayer on the Island has a stake in this. The more voices we have, the harder it becomes for government to ignore us.

This is a rare opportunity. The government has admitted they have £21.3 million they didn’t plan for and don’t need. Let’s make sure it goes back where it belongs – in your pocket.

Act now. Sign the petition. Get your money back.

Together, we can make this happen.

Michael Josem
Manx TaxPayers’ Alliance


Discover more from Manx TaxPayers' Alliance

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Join the Conversation

5 Comments

  1. The government have a simple choice – return OUR money or forever be branded as incompetent liars for claiming to be so skint for all this time. They should pay us back and then resign immediately.

  2. And another thing – WHEN the rebate happens it had better go to private individuals first and not to businesses, especially not to those who help people hide their money.

  3. Our government is a joke. The island needs to get together for a vote of no confidence and scrap whoever is in charge. The mismanagement of money along with countless other things has gone on for far too long. Absolutely useless

  4. Use the money to help fund the health service to give us a first class health service

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *